# \[e-med\] Communiqué OMS-UNICEF : Rappel et destruction de tous les lots de vaccins Shan5 au niveau mondial

**URL:** <https://talk.edrugplus.org/t/e-med-communique-oms-unicef-rappel-et-destruction-de-tous-les-lots-de-vaccins-shan5-au-niveau-mondial/33716>\
**Category:** e-med\
**Created:** [April 29, 2010, 9:23am UTC](https://talk.edrugplus.org/t/e-med-communique-oms-unicef-rappel-et-destruction-de-tous-les-lots-de-vaccins-shan5-au-niveau-mondial/33716 "2010-04-29T09:23:22Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![c.bruneton](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/c/3ec8ea/32.png) [@c.bruneton](https://talk.edrugplus.org/u/c.bruneton)\
**Post date:** [April 29, 2010, 9:23am UTC](https://talk.edrugplus.org/t/e-med-communique-oms-unicef-rappel-et-destruction-de-tous-les-lots-de-vaccins-shan5-au-niveau-mondial/33716/1 "2010-04-29T09:23:22Z")

</div>

L'OMS et l'Unicef ont annoncé lundi dans un communiqué commun le rappel du  
vaccin Shan5 sur avis d'un comité d'experts  
Le vaccin Shan5 est utilisé contre la diphtérie, la coqueluche, le tétanos,  
l'Haemophilus influenzae de type b, et l'hépatite B.  
La société Shantha Biotechnics Ltd., contrôlée par Sanofi-Aventis SA , a  
commencé à rappeler plusieurs lots de vaccins Shan5 au niveau mondial

Joint WHO-UNICEF Statement 2  
26 April 2010  
WHO RECOMMENDS  
RECALL AND DESTRUCTION OF ALL LOTS OF SHAN5 VACCINE  
AS A PRECAUTIONARY MEASURE  
[http://www.who.int/immunization\_standards/vaccine\_quality/who\_unicef\_joint\_statement\_Shan5\_26apr10.pdf](http://www.who.int/immunization_standards/vaccine_quality/who_unicef_joint_statement_Shan5_26apr10.pdf)

The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends as a precautionary measure  
the recall  
and destruction of all lots of the Shantha Biotechnics (India) produced  
pentavalent Shan5  
(DTwP-hepatitis B-Hib) vaccine remaining in stock in countries.  
The Shan5 vaccine currently held in stock in countries should not be used.  
Countries have  
already identified the concerned stock and are now requested to organize  
transport of all  
unused vaccine to central level, in coordination with WHO and UNICEF country  
offices (or  
the in-country entity facilitating the procurement of the vaccines if  
vaccines were not  
supplied through UNICEF or the Pan American Health Organization). Once  
collected, the  
vaccine will handed over to the named Shantha representative in the country  
for  
appropriate handling of return and/or destruction.  
This recommendation is based on the advice of an ad hoc committee of experts  
convened  
on 8 April, following incidents of white sediment sticking to Shan 5 vaccine  
vials that was  
difficult or impossible to resuspend. There have been no reports of any side  
effects from  
the use of Shan5.  
WHO recommends that countries continue vaccination using pentavalent vaccine  
from an  
alternative manufacturer or an alternative DTP-containing vaccine. Countries  
should  
contact WHO or UNICEF country offices (or the in-country entity facilitating  
the shipments  
or procurement of these vaccines) for assistance with ensuring sufficient  
supply of vaccine  
for continuation of immunization programmes.  
Further advice and support on the necessary process for collection, return  
and destruction  
of the vaccine will be provided to the concerned UNICEF/WHO country offices.  
Countries  
supplied through other channels should coordinate directly with a Shantha  
Biotechnics  
representative.

Background  
. During recent months, WHO received vaccine quality complaints from  
Colombia,  
Comoros, and Nepal regarding the presence of a white sediment sticking to  
glass  
vials containing Shan5 vaccine which would not re-suspend even after  
vigorous  
shaking.  
. On 19 February, WHO recommended the temporary suspension of the  
distribution  
and use of specific lots of Shan5 vaccine as a precautionary measure pending  
investigation.  
. On 12 March, WHO recommended that the procurement and use of all lots of  
the  
Shan5 vaccine be temporarily suspended, after WHO received reports that  
additional  
lots, not included in the temporary suspension, showed a similar problem.  
Countries  
were advised to put any remaining vaccine into quarantine until further  
notice.  
. The manufacturer was asked to provide additional data and WHO undertook  
independent testing in WHO-contracted laboratories.  
. WHO called on an ad hoc committee of experts (from regulatory, vaccine  
manufacturing and immunization programme management fields) to review  
reports of  
the investigation from the manufacturer, results of WHO-commissioned tests,  
and the  
physical appearance of the Shan5 vaccine received from the countries.  
Samples of  
lots of the Shan5 vaccine received during the prequalification process and  
other DTP  
combination vaccines were also reviewed.  
. The committee concluded that the batches of the product being held in  
quarantine are  
unsuitable for use and should be destroyed. This recommendation was based on  
several factors: the product has a different physical appearance to that  
which was  
prequalified; there are uncertainties about the safety and immununogenicity  
profile of  
the vaccine in this situation (although no reports of adverse events  
following  
immunization have been received); and the root cause of the change in  
physical  
appearance has not been established.  
Shan5 vaccine quality, safety and efficacy  
Although no reports of adverse events following immunization have been  
received, in view of  
the changed physical appearance of the affected lots, there remain  
uncertainties about the  
safety and immununogenicity profile of the vaccine. While the difficulty in  
resuspending the  
vaccine suggests that the full dose would not be given when using affected  
vials, a change in  
efficacy has not yet been proven..  
Given this, WHO does not recommend revaccination of individuals who have  
received the full  
DTP-hepatitis B-Hib vaccination schedule using Shan5 at present. For  
individuals who have  
begun, but not completed, the schedule using Shan5, an alternative vaccine  
or vaccines  
should be used to complete the schedule.  
Samples from affected vaccine lots are being tested in WHO-contracted  
laboratories, to  
check for a change in immunogenicity. Based on the results of these tests  
WHO will review  
its current advice not to revaccinate children who have received the full  
primary series with  
Shan 5. No other vaccine quality complaints besides the flocculation  
described above have  
been reported to WHO.  
Shan5 vaccine composition and WHO prequalification  
Shan5 is a combined, pentavalent vaccine containing diphtheria and tetanus  
toxoids, whole  
cell pertussis, recombinant DNA derived hepatitis B surface antigen, and  
components of  
Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib). The vaccine is absorbed onto aluminium  
salts as an  
adjuvant and preserved with thiomersal.  
Shan5 remains on the list of WHO prequalified vaccines for the time being.  
If, however, the  
manufacturer is not able to identify the root cause of the quality issue and  
prepare a robust  
plan for corrective action within a period of two months, the product will  
be removed from the  
list of WHO prequalified products. The list of prequalified vaccines on the  
WHO web site  
currently indicates that WHO recommends recall and destruction of remaining  
stocks as a  
precautionary measure.  
Shan5 and alternative vaccine supply  
According to updated estimates, between November 2008 and February 2010,  
almost 24  
million doses of this vaccine were supplied to countries through UNICEF and  
the Pan  
American Health Organization (PAHO) Revolving Fund. The vaccine is also  
procured directly  
by a number of countries.  
UNICEF and PAHO have been working with alternative suppliers of pentavalent  
vaccines  
and with the concerned countries to ensure that there is an adequate  
alternative supply of  
vaccines for continuation of immunization programmes.
