[e-drug] Creating off-label uses (3) - sales reps

E-DRUG: Creating off-label uses (3) - sales reps
---------------------------------------------------------

Dear E-druggers

Sales reps are key promoters of off label-use of drugs, witness the
consistent findings of Prescrire sales reps monitoring network in France.
Biased treatment guidelines and promotion of costly drugs in hospitals are
other sources of off-label uses.

Prescrire sales reps monitoring network was created in 1991 at the
initiative of a group of subscribers. For 15 years, members of the Network
compared sales reps' claims with the information contained in the summaries
of product characteristics.

A variety of methodological precautions were taken to minimise the biases
inherent in any 'sentinel' type of observational system. Results were
remarkably consistent over the years.

Sales reps highlight the efficacy of the drugs they present, often for
unapproved as well as approved indications. In contrast, adverse effects are
not mentioned in three-quarters of visits.

A Prescrire review of the Network¹s findings ³Don't expect sales
representatives to help improve healthcare quality² can be found at:
http://www.prescrire.org/aLaUne/dossierVMbilanEng.php

Prescrire sales reps monitoring network stopped its activity because its
findings were pretty stable over 15 years. Many Prescrire subscribers who
were involved finally decided to stop receiving visits by sales reps. So
this sentinel network was also a kind of intervention study.

Conclusion: no thanks to sales reps in the community and in hospitals.

Christophe Kopp
Staff editor
La revue Prescrire/Prescrire International
www.prescrire.org
Christophe Kopp <ckopp@prescrire.org>

E-DRUG: Sales reps techniques - Academic detailing
-----------------------------------------------------------

['Academic detailing' was first described by Jerry Avorn and Stephen Soumerai about 20 years ago. It is a method of education that uses some of the marketing techniques of sales reps to engage a prescriber in a face-to-face discussion about a specific therapeutic topic.
An early article was 'Principles of educational outreach ('academic detailing') to improve clinical decision making'. S. B. Soumerai and J. Avorn. JAMA Vol. 263 No. 4, January 26, 1990. BS]

Dear all,

in our Mental Health Trust, we are setting up a pharmacy led programme (if we get the money I mean...) whereby our pharmacists will visit General Practitioners in their health centres. This is called "academic detailing" and is strongly based on the structure of drug reps visits. By this programme we are planning to achieve capillary dissemination and promote adherence by local GPs (and patients) to the Psychotropic Monitoring Guidelines we've recently posted on our own website. Our programme also has a strong patient led component (for instance, they'll carry their own blood tests cards, with dates and results).

Something good can be learnt from drug company practice, and used in a way that will truly promote patients' health - or so we hope (we'll know once we have formally evaluated this long-term project).

Valeria

Dr Valeria Frighi
University Dept. of Psychiatry
Neurosciences Building
Warneford Hospital
Oxford
OX3 7JX
UK
"Valeria Frighi" <valeria.frighi@psych.ox.ac.uk>