[e-drug] Distribution strategies for ACTs

E-DRUG: Distribution strategies for ACTs
-----------------------------------------

Dear E-Druggers

Greetings from frozen Britain, where I'm currently doing my Master of Public Health at the University of Leeds.

We had a serious in-class debate about delivery strategies for Artemisinin-Combination Therapies (ACTs) as public health intervention to control malaria in epidemics. The two sides of the argument are:

1) The public health perspective which favours the mass distribution approach using self-treatment and social marketing of ACTs for mass population coverage.

2) On the other hand, there is a strong professional argument which is highly concerned about patients' safety and the serious disadvantages of social marketing and self-treatment approach which may lead to Drug Resistance. This perspective suggests that there should be at least some degree of skill for staff delivering ACTs to the community.

Is there anybody who has evidence OR experience on delivering ACTs by these methods in any context? It will be great to share with us.

Please consider that also your comments and inputs about this argument are highly welcomed and appreciated.

Sincerely

Abu
-------
Abualbishr Alshreef
Postgraduate Student, Master of Public Health (International)
Nuffield Centre for International Health and Development
Leeds Institute of Health Sciences, University of Leeds
United Kingdom
alshreef@ureach.com

E-drug: Distribution strategies for ACTs
----------------------------------------

Dear E-Druggers

I am for the second group. Let there be some degree of skill for the ACT provider because when resistance develops where do we start from. To develop a new drug is not easy and when it eventually comes out it is expensive and unaffordable by the people who will actually benefit from it.

Thank you.

Dr. (Mrs.) B.A. Aina
Dept. of Clinical Pharmacy and Biopharmacy
Faculty of Pharmacy
University of Lagos CMUL Campus,
Idi Araba,Lagos, NIGERA Tel +234 8023091623

Dear E-Druggers,

I second the position of Dr. Aina. For sure we need rational use of
medicines and not mere access (taking into consideration long effects of
inappropriate utilization of ACT-- safety, resistance, etc.).

I have observed some interventions of accelerating access of ACT through Public Private partnership whereby private drug shops are accredited to offer certain services. Before accreditation intensive training of drug dispensers, owners and regulators is conducted. This is coupled with social marketing strategies and improving regulatory mechanisms. I would recommend countries to take initiatives to take the following measures if we want to ensure access of ACT to the remotest areas of the countries:

1. Increase number of authorized outlets to dispense ACT by including private health facilities and drug shops
2. Subsidize ACTs and ensure they are available in private drug shops
3. Conduct intensive training for dispensers and owners; also training of prescribers (the training should be coupled with onsite mentorship)
4. Improve regulatory mechanisms - consider decentralization of inspection of drug outlets to lowest possible level
5. Link drug outlets with social insurance funds
6. Intensify public education on identification of malaria signs and symptoms and rational drug use

Apart from these six points, it is critical to improve proper diagnosis of malaria through scale up of RDTs (this will help to correctly diagnose malaria).

Thanks
..........................................
Mwemezi Elnathan Ngemera, BPharm, MAHMPP
Nuffield Alumni
AIDSRelief Deputy Chief of Party
(Program Quality & Knowledge Mgt)
Catholic Relief Services (CRS)
NO. 144 Migombani Street
P. O. Box 34701 Dar es salaam, Tanzania
Tel: +255222773141, +255713134030
Fax +255222774059
ngemera@gmail.com

E-Drug: Distribution strategies for ACTs (4)
---------------------------------------------

Hi all

In an ideal world, this recipe could work. In the real world it is very
difficult to regulate professional private providers -let alone shop
keepers.

Happy New Year

Regards
Mohga
Dictating to the computer so please forgive silly mistakes

Dr. Mohga M Kamal-Yanni
Senior health & HIV policy advisor
Oxfam GB
John Smith Drive, Oxford, OX4 2JY, UK
Tel: + 44 (0) 1865 472290
Fax + 44 (0) 1865 472245
Mobile + 44 (0)777 62 55 884
Skype Mohga Kamal-Yanni
mkamalyanni@Oxfam.org.uk

E-Drug: Distribution strategies for ACTs (5)
----------------------------------------

Dear E-Druggers

An ideal ACT distribution strategy should meet the following four basic
criteria:
a) promote rational use of medicines,
b) ensure mass population coverage,
c) ensure that the medicine can be used safely by the patients, and
d) prevent/delay the emergence of drug resistance.

The challenge is to find a balance among these competing interests. Below, are my personal views regarding the Zimbabwe’s experiences with ACTs.

a) In an effort to promote rational drug use, numerous public awareness and patient education campaigns have been carried out over the past two years using mass media such as radio, television, and the print media. On the health policy front, the country’s medicines regulatory body is in the process of changing the category of distribution of ACTs so that only the artemether and lumefantrine combination will be available for general use by the public whereas purchasing other ACTs (e.g. Duo-Cotecxin) will require a prescription from a specialist. This measure is intended to curb irrational use of *all* ACTs and to prevent the emergence of drug resistance.

b) In an effort to ensure wider public access to ACTs, the Ministry of Health and Child welfare has (in addition to existing clinics) recently embarked on an ambitious campaign to train Village Health workers (VHW) about how to use Malaria Rapid Diagnostic Tests (RDTs) and ACTs to diagnose and treat malaria. This is born out of the recognition that some degree of skill is required to deliver ACTs. Using VHWs is, in my view, is an elegant way of improving access while promoting rational drug use. Malaria diagnosis using RDTs is critical in preventing haphazard use of ACTs. Since VHW live within the communities and their catchment area often comprises approximately few hundred families, this means that patients don’t have travel long distances in order to access treatment. What’s more, outbreaks of malaria often occur during the rainy season when poor roads and brimming rivers preclude travelling to distant clinics.

Past experiences with chloroquine have taught us that a “mass distribution approach using self-treatment and social marketing” to ensure mass population coverage might not necessarily be the best approach because of potential irrational drug use and concerns about drug resistance. In view of the prohibitive costs (time and money) required to develop new drugs, I believe that using VHW might provide a viable alternative to the self-treatment and social marketing approach by ensuring mass population coverage whilst promoting rational drug use thereby delaying the emergence of drug resistance.

c) In an effort to ensure that ACTs are safe and efficacious, the country recently conducted a study called Cohort Event Monitoring for Artemether/Lumefantrine. The safety and efficacy of ACTs, and emerging drug resistance was assessed in several sentinel sites across the country.

In spite of these measures, access to affordable ACTs in urban areas, which are mainly dependent on the private sector, remains a mammoth challenge. I agree with Mwemezi Elnathan Ngemera “six points plan” especially the suggestion that Public-Private partnerships are needed to address these challenges.

Regards
Mr T A Chizanga
BPharm; M Pharm
Private Pharmacy Practice
Harare, Zimbabwe

E-drug: Distribution strategies for ACTs (6)
--------------------------------------------

Dear all

In an ideal world, this recipe could work. In the real world it is very
difficult to regulate professional private providers -let alone shop
keepers.

A nice point by Mohga - reality bites, not least because WHO has been tepid on Rational Use of Medicines and even where resolutions are taken, funding lags.

And if reality is to be taken into account then there should be more focus on preventative measures as well. Bed nets are good but do make a limited contribution to efficacy.

There are a number of preventative natural solutions that need to complement the curative in addition to rational use of ACTs. For instance, there are numerous plants in Africa that are well known repellents (like Neem which is widely available in East Africa) which can be developed for use with a little cost and education and initiative. Indian firms have developed a range of products based on Neem, but perhaps there is need to see if a less "consumerist" orientation can be brought to bear. By this I mean whether Neem (fresh/dried) can be adapted for use to keep the bugs away... in a way that it remains as close to nature as possible (simple Neem leaf "dust" does the trick in my limited experience) ... of course this is potentially a solution where there would hardly be any money to be made but that should not preclude it as a solution...

Riaz Tayob
SEATINI
riaz.tayob@gmail.com