[e-drug] New report on price, availability and affordability of medicines for chronic diseases (5)

E-DRUG: New report on price, availability and affordability of medicines for chronic diseases (5)
--------------------------------------

Dear All:

The recent WHO/HAI report on disparities in price, availabilty and
affordability of medicines for chronic diseases is important work. This
entire subject matter as it relates to chronic diseases deserves wider
appreciation and understanding.

It should not be allowed to be filed away on shelves to gather dust- which
is a rather roundabout way of asking the question "How can the contents of
such a report be leveraged in effective ways?". I would invite e-drug
colleagues to give this some thought.

Can we:

1. Teach and or otherwise disseminate the contents of this report to
chronic, non-communicable disease public health/management courses in
universities in the U.S. and abroad.

2. Encourage a dialog between practitioners and the private sector at one or
more regional/sub-regional meetings to further discuss the implications of
this report.

3. Create "access to medicines" campaigns based on existing campaigns for
infectious disease meds .. or perhaps medicines for chronic,
non-communicable diseases requires a different model.

My sense is that this particular "access" issue lies well under the radar
for most persons who are not on e-drug.

Warren Kaplan, Ph.D, JD, MPH
Assistant Professor of International Health

Center for International Health and Development
Boston University School of Public Health
85 E. Concord St.
Boston, MA 02118
ph. 617: 414- 1152
fax. 617: 414- 1261
wak@bu.edu
alternate e mail: wak22@comcast.net

New report on price, availability and affordability of medicines for chronic diseases (6)
----------------------------------

Dear all,
  It is quite a challenge to try and bring chronic diseases on the agenda when majority of deaths in developing countries is still infectious diseases! As a public health practictioner from a developing country, it is obvious to me that we can gain a lot more mileage dealing with infectious diseases, including respiratory infections, other than the well known HIV/AIDS,Malaria and TB. However,perhaps there is need right now to evaluate whether the attention given to HIV/TB/malaria is bearing fruit.
   
  As a hospital pharmacist, I see the need not to ignore the matter of chronic illness management, as I am faced by these patients every day. However, the reality on the ground is that these patients with a chronic illness are much more likely to die from an infection, than the chronic illness itself.
   
  Of course access to proper treatment and care,for example in Asthma, remains a challenge. In Kenya,we are still grappling with the basics of how to diagnose asthma, particularly in children. Due to the myriad environmental pollutants, we know that asthma is prevalent, but,in real life, how does one differentiate asthma from chronic bronchitis or any other COPD? Is there need to split hairs? Who has peak flow meters in their budgets? Kenya has recently launched guidelines for the diagnosis and management of asthma. We wait to see if practice will change.
   
  When asthma diagnosis in the young is finally made, parental acceptance is still very poor. Once treatment is started, the transfer of knowledge on the various inhaler techniques is still a challenge. In the case of children, there is the added cost of the use of spacers, which are much more expensive than the inhalers themselves. Physicians still prescribe oral salbutamol,long term antihistamines and ephedrine derivatives for asthma management! The use of steroids is gaining ground, albeit slowly as the perceived fear of steroid side effects is huge. Perhaps this is because a lot of steroid use is still oral prednisolone.
   
  Can this area of chronic disease management be dealt with like HIV/AIDs where there is some form of pre and post diagnosis counseling, followed by agressive adherence counseling and support?
   
  I agree however,that any disparities must be dealt with. At the moment, anyone diagnosed with a chronic illness in a developing country is prescribed a death sentence. As a tertiary referral hospital,we are unable to regularly make available anticancers, antidiabetics (except insulin at cost to the patient), and other medicines for chronic illnesses, as we cannot afford them in the government budgets. Patients are often very willing to raise funds and purchase the first course of therapy as they are desparate for a solution, but they soon are unable to continue. Private pharmacies do not regularly stock such expensive medicines as they remain "dead stock". So,in effect,even where individual patients could afford to buy the medicines, they might not get it easily.
   
  The other challenge with chronic disease management is the need for regular diagnostic support for follow up and maintenance of therapy. The diabetic patient needs ability to monitor blood glucose levels regulalry. the hypertensive needs to monitor blood pressure regularly, Peak flow meters for asthma patients etc. These gadgets are costly and are hardly remembered in any budget.

[Thank you Atieno for this important message. Your description of the situation comprises very relevant points to bear in mind. I have worked in countries where donations of medicines would come, but e.g. no diagnostics... As for antibiotics, please visit the HAI database (www.haiweb.org/medicineprices) for data on antibiotics. They are at least as unaffordable! KM, moderator]
   
  Atieno Ojoo, BPharm, MPH
  Chief Pharmacist,Kenyatta National Hospital
  P O Box 20723
  Nairobi,Kenya
  Tel 254 (0)20 272 6300 ext 43515
  atisojoo@yahoo.co.uk

E-DRUG: New report on price, availability and affordability of medicines for chronic diseases (7)
-------------------------------------------------

Dear all,

The message posted by Atieno hits the nail right on the head. Especially
since in most of the Caribbean chronic non-communicable diseases are the
leading cause of death. In Suriname, cardiovascular diseases, including
cardiovascular accidents count for nearly 30% of mortality. Diabetes
Mellitus aacounts for about 5% (in Barbados the percentage is even higher),
and they are on the rise, as is cancer. Treatment and management of these
diseases presses hard on the budgets of our nations. Also we lack the human
resources to incorporate chronic disease management in our health care
delivery.

At a WTO/TRIPS meeting in Antigua in 2005, representatives of the Ministries
of Health of 4 Caribbean countries, expressed their concern about the price
and accessibility for patients needing drugs for chronic non-communicable
diseases, as it pertains to TRIPS. The letter can be seen at the following
link

http://crnm.org/documents/the_representatives_of_the_moh.pdf

In Suriname we try to incorporate HIV and AIDS care in our regular
healthcare delivery structures. Where deficiencies are noted, we try to
strengthen our overall capacity for implementing disease prevention measures
and disease management structures, however, when using donor funds, we
sometimes have to admit that we are on the road to create an 'elite patient'
for lack of better words.

At the beginning of this month Surinamese pharmacists firmly expressed the
view in a Caribbean Association of Pharmacist mid-term meeting that in the
management of opportunistic infections in AIDS, we find it unethical to
deliver earmarked medicines to AIDS patients alone, where other patients may
benefit from the same treatment. We were however appraised by some
colleagues that they find themselves hard pressed by donors to do exactly
this.

We need to convince both national policy makers and international donors of
the importance of this issue. I can only hope that in the (near) future,
more attention is being given to these matters and that we should find the
middle road in applying the lessons learned in HIV, malaria and TB care to
general healthcare delivery. Sharing experience in this matter will be a
first step on this long but important road!

Miriam Naarendorp, RPh
Pharmacy Policy Coordinator
MOH Suriname
naarendo@sr.net